Wood-Burning vs. Gas Fireplaces: What’s Best for Bay Area Homeowners?
Choosing the right fireplace for your home isn’t just about ambiance—it’s also about efficiency, maintenance, and meeting local regulations. In the Bay Area, homeowners must also consider air quality laws, environmental impact, and long-term operating costs when choosing between a wood-burning or gas fireplace. Peninsula Chimney Service breaks down the pros and cons of each option to help you decide what’s best for your space, lifestyle, and community.
Benefits of a Wood-Burning Fireplace
Classic Ambiance and Tradition:
There’s something undeniably nostalgic about a wood-burning fireplace—the crackle, the aroma, the warmth. For many homeowners, it’s an experience that gas just can’t replicate. Wood-burning fireplaces offer a traditional focal point and can add charm to both modern and historic homes.
Fuel Availability and Cost:
Firewood is widely available and often affordable, especially if you have access to your own supply. In some rural areas, wood may be a more cost-effective fuel option during the colder months.
Works During Power Outages:
Unlike some gas fireplaces, wood-burning units do not rely on electricity to operate. This makes them a reliable source of heat during power outages—important in areas where PG&E shutoffs or storms are common.
Considerations for Wood Fireplaces in the Bay Area
Air Quality Regulations:
The Bay Area Air Quality Management District (BAAQMD) places strict restrictions on wood burning, especially on “Spare the Air” days when air pollution levels are high. These rules may limit when and how often you can use your fireplace.
More Maintenance Required:
Wood-burning fireplaces require regular chimney cleaning to remove creosote and soot buildup. Without proper maintenance, they pose a higher risk of chimney fires and ventilation issues.
Lower Efficiency:
Traditional wood-burning fireplaces are less efficient than gas when it comes to heating. Much of the heat escapes through the chimney, and they can actually pull warm air out of the home if not properly sealed.
Advantages of a Gas Fireplace
Clean-Burning and Energy Efficient:
Gas fireplaces produce far fewer emissions than wood and are typically 70–90% efficient, meaning most of the heat stays inside your home. They’re a great choice for environmentally conscious homeowners.
Ease of Use and Maintenance:
With the flip of a switch or push of a remote, you get instant fire—no kindling, logs, or ash cleanup required. Maintenance is minimal, and there’s no creosote buildup to worry about.
Compatible with Bay Area Air Quality Rules:
Because gas fireplaces don’t emit harmful particulates like wood does, they’re not restricted on Spare the Air days. This means more consistent and legal use throughout the year.
Drawbacks to Consider with Gas Fireplaces
Higher Installation Costs:
Gas lines must be professionally installed if your home doesn’t already have one, which can raise upfront costs. Venting requirements may also vary depending on the type of unit you choose (direct vent vs. ventless).
Lacks Traditional Fireplace Feel:
While gas logs are becoming increasingly realistic, some homeowners still prefer the sensory experience of real wood fires. However, gas fireplaces continue to improve in appearance and ambiance.
Dependent on Utilities:
Although many models have backup systems, some gas fireplaces rely on electricity to function. This could be a disadvantage during outages unless a battery backup is installed.
Which Fireplace Is Right for You?
Choose Wood-Burning If:
You value the sensory experience of real wood fires
You live in a less regulated area or only use your fireplace occasionally
You want a fireplace that can provide heat even during power outages
Choose Gas If:
You want a low-maintenance, efficient, and clean-burning option
You plan to use your fireplace regularly
You live in a more regulated part of the Bay Area and want to avoid air quality restrictions
Let Peninsula Chimney Service Help You Decide
Serving homeowners across the San Francisco Bay Area—from San Mateo and Burlingame to Mountain View and Menlo Park—Peninsula Chimney Service offers expert consultation, installation, and maintenance for both gas and wood-burning fireplaces. We provide:
Professional Assessments: Helping you choose the right system based on your home, budget, and preferences
Installation & Upgrades: From retrofitting old wood fireplaces with gas inserts to full system installs
Regulatory Guidance: Ensuring your system complies with BAAQMD regulations and local codes
Ongoing Maintenance: Keeping your fireplace and chimney in top condition, no matter what type you choose
Ready to upgrade or install a new fireplace in your Bay Area home? Contact Peninsula Chimney Service today to schedule a consultation and find the fireplace that fits your lifestyle.
